Enable Flash Menu and Allow Fullscreen variables for Flash not working

[Satya Minnekanti]

To reproduce the defect:

Scenario 1:

1. open CK Editor sample and click on Flash icon.

2. In the Flash Properties dialog, enter following URL (​http://www.youtube.com/v/9vksHsiold0?fs=1) in URL field, uncheck the check box Allow full screen on properties tab & click OK button

3. Click on Remove Editor button.

Expected Result:

Enable Full Screen option should not be shown for the flash video.

Actual Result:

FF & Safari it is showing Full Screen option for the flash video.

Scenario 2:

1. open CK Editor sample and click on Flash icon.

2. In the Flash Properties dialog, enter following URL (​http://www.youtube.com/v/9vksHsiold0?fs=1) in URL field, uncheck the check box Enable flashmenu on properties tab & click OK button.

3. Click on Remove Editor button.

Expected Result:

Enable Full Screen option should be shown for the flash video and When we open context menu on the flash video it should not show flash menu options(Quality, Zoom, Print & Show all).

Actual Result:

IE & Opera it is not showing the Enable Full Screen option for the flash video.

IE When we open context menu on the flash video it is showing flash menu options(Quality, Zoom, Print & Show all).

[Krzysztof Studnik]

Scenario 1

• confirmed. Button is shown, but video, does not go to fullscreen when button is pressed.
  

Scenario 2

• confirmed for first part
• cannot reproduce, that menu contains options: Quality, Zoom, Print & Show all, when option Flash menu is disabled.

[Piotrek Koszuliński]

I cannot reproduce this issue on Firefox and Chrome on Mac. If the content returned by the editor is correct and fullscreen can still be enabled on some browser on some OS then it's the Flash's bug.

[Wiktor Walc]

Confirmed on Fedora, Flash 15.0.0.189. In my case I was able to turn on/off full screen mode, but only when fs=1 was missing at the end of the URL.

​https://developers.google.com/youtube/player_parameters#fs

Note that fs itself has a special meaning:

fs (supported players: AS3, HTML5)

Values: 0 or 1. The default value is 1, which causes the fullscreen button to display. 
Setting this parameter to 0 prevents the fullscreen button from displaying.

[Piotrek Koszuliński]

CKEditor has nothing to do here. It correctly sets the allowFullscreen param. The browser must then correctly handle it. For example, in Chrome it currently works like this:

1. When the allowFullscreen option is set to true, I can turn on the FS mode regardless of the URL to YT video.
2. When the allowFullscreen option is set to false, the [] icon is still visible in YT player, but it does nothing (the FS mode cannot be turned on).

I'm closing this ticket as invalid.