IsDirty giving false positive with no content.

[Josh Ritter]

Using 2.5 in ff2. Loading fck with empty content and calling IsDirty and it is returning true. Adding content opening a fresh window and calling IsDirty then returns false. My demo is setup @ ​http://ritter.eplt.washington.edu/tools/fckeditor.

I tried to test this against your demo version, but every example I found on your site was pre-loaded with content.

[Wojciech Olchawa]

Confirmed using FCKeditor 2.6 and the latest SVN. The bug occurs in FF2 as well as in IE.

[Matti Järvinen]

fixes IE7 FF3 isDirty failure with empty value

[Matti Järvinen]

IE7 and FF3 handle empty values differently.

With oEditor.setData(,true):

FF StartupValue <br> IE StartupValue

FF EditorDocument.body.innerHTML '<p><br></p>' IE7 EditorDocument.body.innerHTML '<P></P>'

So oEditor.IsDirty() == true

I hacked something together to fix this in editor/_source/internals/fck.js replace IsDirty (line 63) with isDirty function in isDirtyChange.js

In no way the fix is complete since I do not know how this appears in Safari or other supported browsers.

[Matti Järvinen]

Yes I have this problem in 2.6.3

oEditor.setData(,true); oEditor.isDirty(); true

[Alfonso Martínez de Lizarrondo]

Stop changing the version field.

If it was fixed in 2.6.3 then the ticket would be closed, not open. It must be used to note the first version where the problem was present, not the last one, because that would mean that it's the latest version in all the open tickets, so it would be useless.

[Piotrek Koszuliński]

This issue expired.